Cell Biochemistry Martinsried

Cytomics, from Prognostic to Predictive Medicine


(from: Purdue CD-ROM Vol.8 2004 ISBN 1-890473-C6-5)

1. Background: The future development of diseases is addressed in most instances as prognosis. Prognosis reflects the average statistical experience with disease development in large patient groups under therapy. Prognostic indicators are often used for patient stratification in therapy optimizing trials in an effort to treat as many patients as possible with the most efficient therapy.

- A frequently encountered problem concerns larger or smaller subgroups of patients who will not benefit from standard therapy and potentially suffer from therapeutic side effects and adverse drug reactions (ADRs).

- It would be a significant help for the clinician if a-priori non responder patients could be identified pretherapeutically (L1, L2 ). This would allow individualized therapy modifications as well as the use of alternative or preventive therapies.

- One may think that the description of more and more independent prognostic factors may automatically lead to prediction. This is not necessarily true since prognosis addresses patient groups and not individual patients. Smoking as an example is a good prognostic indicator for later lung cancer but no good predictor since not all smokers will develop lung cancer and lung cancer is also observed in non smokers for other reasons.

2. Goal: With this in mind it seems important to specifically orient multiparameter data analysis in cytometry, chip or bead arrays, clinical chemistry and clinical parameters towards individualized predictions with > 95% or > 99% accuracy.

Individualized predictions in multiparameter data analysis can be addressed by data sieving as a fast operating algorithmic method which requires no mathematical assumptions on the value distributions of analysed parameters and no substitution of missing data values or removal of patients with incomplete data sets. The resulting discriminatory data patterns characterize the molecular cell phenotypes in disease as they result from genotype and exposure. The data patterns are of interest for bottom-up hypothesis development and molecular reverse engineering of complex intracellular processes.

3. Results: Individualized risk assessment or prediction of therapeutic success by data sieving analysis was amongst other possible in: acute myeloid leukemia (AML), diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL), colorectal cancer, intensive care medicine, cardiac surgery and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) (further examples, Cell Biochemistry, Martinsried).

- The comparison of predictive and prognostic data patterns seems of particular importance because it may explain the inhomogeneuus therapeutic response in prognostically well characterized patient groups.

- Predictive and prognostic data patterns show only a limited coincidence of selected parameters in AML ( pred, prog) and DLBCL ( pred, prog).

4. Conclusion: The multiparameter cytometric or other molecular information which is typically collected in the clinical environment has the potential for an accurate pretherapeutic identification of risk patients (individualized pretherapeutic risk assessment) as evidenced by an increasing number of examples from everyday medical practice.

- Besides obvious advantages for the individual patient, the differences in predictive and prognostic data patterns allow significant new insights into the heterogeneity and variability of disease processes.

- Considering the development of new drugs, the availability of disease specific predictive and prognostic data patterns provides substantially increased possibilities for the identification of suitable candidate target genes in pharmaceutical developments.

Literature References:
L1 Valet G. Predictive Medicine by Cytomics: Potential and Challenges. JBRHA 16:164-167, (2002)
L2 Valet G: Past and present concepts in flow cytometry: A European perspective. JJBRHA 17:213-222, (2003)

© 2024 G.Valet
1965-2006: Max-Planck-Institut für Biochemie, Am Klopferspitz 18a, D-82152 Martinsried, Germany
Last Update: Apr.10,2004
First display: Apr 3,2003